
Who is that one person you trust to read your work?
I don't know who yours is, but we all have one. Or should have one. And mine has rotated through the years. From a trusted college friend who kept me from flinging early plays over a freeway overpass... to my husband at the time who helped me understand I had a writing career because I was funny not just lucky. When we got divorced unfortunately the role of my writing buddy went with him.
Those times between writing confidantes can be scary. Showing your massive insecurities scribbled on paper to a new person is arduous. Will they love you? Will they trash you? A writing teacher I had once said, "If somebody called you a bad driver... would you stop driving? Of course not. But when people don't like your writing you're willing to throw it away? Why does their opinion matter more than yours?"
Years ago while searching for the right writing confidante I asked a good good friend to read a script I was working on. When it came time to give me notes, he didn't give me notes... he SKEWERED me with notes. It was like a pencil through the heart. Nothing was worthy of his praise. Everything I did seemed shoddy. By the end I even questioned my comma placement. I was stunned. My sweet buddy turned into a literary Cujo in the time it took to read a script. Years later another friend told me he had asked this same friend to read something and he shredded him as well. The point being, he is who he is. He's a bad note giver. And now we know. And we will never ask him again. Never. Ever. But he remains one of my favorite dinner companions and that's enough.
Now the arduous task of reading my first drafts and propping up my fragile ego lies with my fiance. A very smart compassionate man. He neither shreds me or lies to me, he's just honest. And it's hard for me to ask anybody to read anything. I'm wasting their time... I should know how to do this myself... My mind goes many places but "You are brilliant -- move on" isn't one of them.
The thing I've learned about my fiance is... he LOVES to give notes. He will give notes on an old movie we see on the couch together... like the director isn't dead and is longing to take another crack at the battlefield scene. At concerts he's been known to tell a soundboard guy that his levels are off. (and surprisingly they usually thank him) My favorite notes though were the notes given in Amsterdam. We went to a live sex show in the redlight district (oh, don't judge, it's like their Disneyland) and this girl was doing a... let's say "novelty act" with a lit cigar. And during this dubious act to rock music my fiance leaned over to me, irritated and said... "She's not puffing on the beat!" Thirty people in the room and I can guarantee no one was thinking about her rhythm but him. I was mostly hoping she was well-paid to do something that would kill her grandmother.
I practically had to restrain him from giving her notes on the way out where she was enjoying a hard-earned cigarette. From another, ah, orifice.
So for once I don't feel guilty asking someone to read what I've written. He always has, need I say... the notes.
(Photo)


